Grading

Diamond Clarity Chart

Eleven grades from Flawless to I3, judged at ten power magnification rather than by eye. That distinction is where most of the overspending in this category happens.

The full scale

GradeStands forWhat is in thereClean to the eye?
FLFlawlessNothing, inside or out, at 10xYes
IFInternally FlawlessSurface marks onlyYes
VVS1Very Very Slightly Included 1Extremely hard to see at 10xYes
VVS2Very Very Slightly Included 2Very hard to see at 10xYes
VS1Very Slightly Included 1Minor, needs effort at 10xYes
VS2Very Slightly Included 2Minor, findable at 10xYes
SI1Slightly Included 1Noticeable at 10xUsually
SI2Slightly Included 2Easy at 10xSometimes not
I1Included 1Obvious at 10xNo
I2Included 2Obvious, affects brillianceNo
I3Included 3Heavy, may affect durabilityNo

The phrase that matters: at 10x

Every grade on that chart is assigned by a grader looking through a ten power loupe. Nobody wearing a ring is doing that, and nobody looking at your hand across a table is either.

Which means the practical question is not what grade the stone has, but whether anything shows without magnification. From VS2 upward the answer is no. That is the line where money stops buying appearance and starts buying rarity on paper.

Where the inclusion sits beats what grade it is

Two SI1 stones can look completely different. An inclusion directly under the table in the middle of the stone sits in the most visible spot there is. The same inclusion out near the girdle disappears under a prong and nobody will ever see it.

This is why an SI1 you have looked at is a better buy than a VS1 you have not. Ask for the plotted diagram on the certificate, which shows where the inclusions are, and look at the stone.

What the inclusions actually are

Pinpoints are tiny crystals, the most common thing you will see. Clouds are clusters of them, and a dense cloud can make a stone look hazy even at a decent grade, which is worth watching for. Feathers are small fractures and are usually harmless unless large and surface-reaching. Crystals are included minerals, sometimes dark enough to spot by eye at SI2 and below.

Not sure what you are looking at?

Photograph the stone and the app gives you a visual read on the 4Cs, an estimated value range, and what to check next. Free on iOS and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Frequently asked questions

What is the lowest clarity that still looks clean?
VS2 is clean to the naked eye essentially always. SI1 usually is, depending on where the inclusions sit: one under the table in the centre is far more noticeable than the same inclusion tucked near the girdle where a prong will cover it. SI2 is a coin toss and needs to be seen before buying.
What does the number after VS or SI mean?
It splits each band in two, with 1 being cleaner than 2. So VS1 is cleaner than VS2, and SI1 is cleaner than SI2. The grades are otherwise the same category of inclusion, just less or more of it.
Is flawless worth paying for?
Only if you want the certificate. Flawless and Internally Flawless stones are genuinely rare, which is what you are paying for, but the visual difference against a good VS2 at arm's length is zero. If it is going on a hand rather than in a safe, the money is better spent on cut.
Do inclusions weaken a diamond?
Almost never in practice, with one exception: a large feather reaching the surface near the girdle can be a structural risk if the stone takes a hard knock in the wrong place. Any decent grader will flag that. Ordinary pinpoints and clouds have no effect on durability.

Worth being clear: everything here, and the app itself, is an educational reference. At-home tests narrow things down, they do not certify a stone. Before you buy, sell or insure anything of real value, get it looked at by a certified gemologist or an independent appraiser.

Related